In it, but not of it. TPM DC

The complicated state of the Senate stimulus debate just got more intense.

Sen. Olympia Snowe (ME), one of the four Republicans considered genuinely open to cooperation with Democrats on a workable economic recovery bill, just released a statement saying she was approached by Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) to come up with a list of trims from the $275 billion-plus tax section of the stimulus.

To be clear, this is separate from the $80 bilion-plus package of spending cuts that are being hashed out by a group of 15 or so centrist senators from both parties.

Pruning the tax section of the stimulus is an idea that could hold promise for liberals, many of whom are concerned about the hits that education and transit would take in the centrist senators' package of cuts. The portion Snowe is looking at contains plenty of cuts, for both businesses and individuals -- some of them added in the hopes of winning GOP support -- but also a number of tax credits that could take money out of government coffers in the short term while increasing economic growth in the long term.

All told, trimming the tax section while retaining its (partially questionable) economic benefits is a tricky balance, but one Snowe is uniquely qualified for as a popular member of the Finance Committee. Speaking of, senator, may I suggest that $15 billion could be saved by eliminating the questionable "carryback" tax credit extension?

But adding tax changes to the mix adds a new obstacle to Reid's goal of passing the stimulus by day's end.

Fundamentally, the talks at this point hinge on keeping enough Democrats on board with the proposed spending cuts while firming up the commitment of the 2-4 Republicans needed for passage. In the words of one of those GOPers, Arlen Specter (PA), "If [Reid] had [the votes], he would have used them last night."

Snowe's full statement is after the jump.

Read More →

The Coleman campaign appears to have found a genuine example of a particular type of absentee ballot being treated differently throughout the state, in their central claim of Equal Protection -- but it seems like they're effectively fishing for votes for Al Franken.

Coleman lawyer Joe Friedberg has been looking into a category that has come to be known as "3-A" ballots, where a newly-registering voter put their registration form inside the secrecy envelope containing the ballot, rather than immediately within the outer return envelope as they were supposed to. Many local officials now believe those should be counted.

The problem is in figuring out how to identify them. It would involve opening up the secrecy envelope, remaining blind to the actual vote inside, and feeling for that extra card. As it turns out, Anoka County elections manager Rachel Smith said her county had been doing just that. Other county officials have said they didn't do this, though it may have occurred here and there.

Coleman attorney/spokesman Ben Ginsberg played this up at a lunch-time press conference. "So there is a difference between counties," Ginsberg said. "It allowed more votes to be counted in Anoka than potentially those other two counties [Ramsey and Washington]."

Read More →

Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) is trying to get some answers on two potential cases of Bush political appointees "burrowing" into long-term positions at the Pentagon's detainee affairs office.

One of the two has right of return to a civil service position, according to the AP, but let's look for a moment at the second official -- Tara Jones, a special assistant in the detainee office.

Jones was a central figure in the "Pentagon Pundits" scandal, helping to coordinate the military's courtship of former officers who used TV appearances to promote George W. Bush's Iraq war policies. When the New York Times first broke the pundits story, using internal e-mails obtained through the Freedom of Information Act, it was Jones' account that the newspaper had asked to view. (The full complement of her publicly released emails is obtainable here.)

One would think Jones' past might make it easier for Feinstein to ensure she doesn't burrow into the system -- but that likely depends on what explanation the senator gets from the Pentagon.

We reported on Wednesday that the Obama administration's new executive pay limits -- which have huge loopholes built in -- weren't stopping Sen. Claire McCaskill (D-MO) from pushing to add her own, stronger CEO pay caps to the stimulus bill.

And very quietly, by unanimous voice vote, McCaskill's plan was added to the stimulus last night. The Senate also added Banking Committee Chairman Chris Dodd's (D-CT) similar executive pay constraints to the bill. So it seems that GOPers may talk about not wanting government in control of private business; but when push comes to shove, even they can no longer defend the excesses of Wall Street.

A new Gallup poll explains why Democrats are now so eager to connect the anti-stimulus bill Republicans to Rush Limbaugh, and to set up Rush as the new Leader of the Opposition: Independents hate him, he can galvanize Democrats...and Republican voters actually do like him.

Limbaugh's favorable-unfavorable numbers among Republicans stand at 60%-23%. Among independents, though, he's at just 25%-45%. And Democrats definitely have it in for him at 6%-63%. Multiplying out the partisan subsets in this poll, we get an overall top-line result of 28% favorability for Limbaugh across the country, compared to 45% unfavorable.

So if Limbaugh does become a national issue, the data shows he could be a net plus for the Dems -- though the obvious caveat exists that swing voters could have more important things to worry about than some radio loudmouth.

A funny dynamic right now in the Minnesota election trial is how both campaigns have lists of rejected absentee ballots that they're trying to get reconsidered for admission -- and both of them have set out to demonstrate how the other guy's catalog is complete garbage.

Earlier this morning in the Minnesota trial, Coleman lawyer Joe Friedberg went through some of Franken's current list with Anoka County elections manager Rachel Smith, having her affirm that there were various problems within the Anoka section: The ballots had arrived late, were missing voter signatures, or witness signatures, etc. Franken's team hasn't had the chance to cross-examine Smith yet, so we'll see how they do on these votes.

It's to be expected that the vast majority of re-reviewed ballots from both sides will have some serious problems -- and Coleman's certainly have -- as most of them were rejected at least a second time by local officials during a separate review this past December. The issue here is more about what might happen if any leniency ends up being brought to the process, such as forgiving an error if it's determined to have been an election official's fault, not the voter's.

Coleman's list started out at 654, and has now expanded to 4,797 with the court's permission. Franken's team started at 771 ballots, and they have a pending request to expand their group after Coleman got to do it. And of course, both sides' lists so far have come from their own geographic strongholds, as well. So this will take a while.

Despite a rousing, psych-you-up speech from President Obama last night, the Senate is still facing the same core dilemma on the economic recovery bill.

Call it the Goldilocks problem. The 15 centrist senators still in talks on slicing about $100 billion from the bill have yet to hit on a package of spending cuts that's not too hot, not too cold, but just right to get the stimulus to 60 votes.

If they don't figure it out by day's end, Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) will do what I suspected he'd ultimately have to -- move to cut off debate on the bill entirely, setting up a Sunday vote that will test all this talk of resistance from centrists on both sides.

One thing that bears repeating throughout today's Senate drama: This debate over trimming the stimulus is spending little time on what it means to cut as much as $13 billion in state education aid and $5.5 billion in surface transportation funding. The process is just moving too fast.

"It's very hard to get your case made in a fully substantive way," Sen. Kent Conrad (D-ND), one of the dozen-plus negotiators, admitted last night. (He had just finished asserting that "substance matters here, what's in the package matters a lot.")

So by all means, call your senator and holler if you saw something on the list of potential cuts that concerns you.

Remember the case of Kathie Olsen, the Bush political appointee who's now safely ensconced in a suspiciously junior position at the same agency where she was once the No. 2?

Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) thinks she's uncovered a similar situation at the Pentagon's Office of Detainee Affairs, where former Bushies are still involved in politically sensitive debates over the Guantanamo Bay prison. Feinstein wrote to Defense Secretary Robert Gates on Wednesday seeking an inquiry into whether two political appointees "have been improperly converted to career positions within the Department of Defense." From her letter:

Read More →

Obama To Stimulus Critics: Spending "Is The Whole Point" President Obama spoke last night to the House Democrats, where he rallied support for the stimulus bill -- and hammered the opposition. "They say this isn't a stimulus bill. It's a spending bill," said Obama. "Well, that's the whole point." A full transcript is available here.

Obama's Day Ahead: Discussing The Economy, And Gitmo President Obama and Paul Volcker are holding an 11:15 a.m. event at the White, to introduce members of the President's Economic Recovery Advisory Board. At 3:30 p.m., Obama will be holding a closed meeting at the White House with family members of the victims of 9/11 and the USS Cole bombing, in order to discuss his decision to close the detention camp at Guantanamo Bay -- a decision that has been strongly objected to by some of the people he'll be meeting today.

Biden Speaking To House Dems, Then Heading To Germany Joe Biden will be speaking today to the House Democratic Issues Conference in Williamsburg, Virginia. He will then travel to Germany, where he will be representing the United States at the 45th Munich Conference on Security Policy.

Reid Wants To Hold Stimulus Vote Today The Washington Post reports that Harry Reid hopes to hold a vote on final passage of the stimulus bill today, after yesterday's negotiations with a small handful of Senate Republicans dragged on. If today's effort fails, Reid will call for a Sunday session.

Hillary Going To Asia For First Overseas Trip As Secretary Hillary Clinton is set to go to Asia for her first overseas trip the Secretary of State, visiting Japan, South Korea, China and Indonesia. She is scheduled to embark on her trip on February 15.

Steele Shakes Up RNC, Asks For Resignations The Hill reports that Michael Steele is undertaking a top-to-bottom review of the Republican National Committee's staff, asking all top staffers to submit their resignations. Some of them could be rehired, but the ironically named "state victory directors" won't be coming back.

Poll: GOPer Ahead In Virginia-Gov. Race, But It's Still Wide Open A new Rasmussen poll shows Virginia Attorney General Bob McDonnell leading all three Democrats in the open race for governor, though the undecided numbers remain high: McDonnell leads state Senator Creigh Deeds 39%-30%, is ahead of former state Delegate Brian Moran 39%-36%, and leads Terry McAuliffe 42%-35%.

Obama Takes First Ride On Air Force One President Obama took his first ride as the sitting president on Air Force One last night, as he traveled to the House Dems' retreat in Williamsburg. Said Obama to the reporters: "Hey guys, what do you think of my -- this spiffy ride here?"